One of Many – Two Great Detectives

Around about the time I turned eleven I started to read adult literature. Amongst my early reads were two great crime writers, who’d written about very different characters – Arthur Conan Doyle and Ed McBain.

sherlock holmesI was, still am,  a huge Sherlock Holmes fan. I lapped up the short stories, book after book. The four novels he wrote appealed to me less, especially Hound of the Baskervilles, still don’t see why that one is lauded. Conan Doyle was the master of the short story – he conveyed enough plot and pace to make those pages race by. I loved the analytical powers of Holmes, the dogged determination of Watson and the variety of plots.

cop hater

The first

Ed McBain began writing his 87th Precinct series in the 1950s and continued until the year he died in 2005. Long before HIll Street Blues and NYPD Blue became popular, McBain was the master of ensemble police characters. He wrote about  detectives, and he portrayed likeable rogues, bigots, and the hardworking family man. My favourite – Steve Carella with his deaf mute wife and twins, formed the backbone of the books.

The last

The last

McBain’s true gift was to write across five decades about the same characters and only age them by about ten years. While fashions changed, police procedures evolved and forensic technology improved, he maintained the same cast but simply had them adapt to new things without commenting on their absence in previous books. Conan Doyle did a similar thing when he brought Holmes back to life. Now it’s become a popular habit to transplant a historical character into a contemporary setting and maintain his appeal – in Holmes case, the peculiar character traits of a genius.

I’m not into sadistic serial killers, sickening crimes or mad men. McBain wrote about drug related crime, jealous lovers, revenging villains and unfortunate prostitutes, and he especially concentrated on procedure, witty dialogue and fast pace.

Two different authors, but much in common when I look back on those early reads. Detectives immersed in their practices, good plots, an eye for detail and no over the top baddies, for the most part (Sherlock had Moriarty and McBain created the Deaf Man)

I’ve a full collection of both sets of books on my shelves, which for McBain amounts to several dozen and some were printed back in the days of shilling and pence. I’ll treasure these.


Comments are always welcome.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

The Bridgehunter's Chronicles

Bridging our past with the future by preserving our heritage in the present.


random, eclectic, see how my mind works

The Old Shelter

Dieselpunk author - Historical Fantasy Set in the 1920s


Kiddie Talkies - Have a look at this World through a kid's eyes with the help of his Mom's expressions

Rebekah Loper, Author

Character-driven epic fantasy. Resilient women. A touch of romance.

Wolf of Words

Stories, Reviews and Opinions!

Iain Kelly

Fiction Writing


it wouldn't be thewirralgirl without you.

Rachel Walkley

Telling Tales, Revealing Secrets

Author Erika Jayne

Where stories come to life

Living the Dream

Susanne Matthews

Stories I Found in the Closet

The musings of writer, mother, musician and whatever else takes my fancy

Planet Pailly

Where Science Meets Fiction

True North Bricks

Canadian LEGO® Fan Media

Tossing It Out

The musings of writer, mother, musician and whatever else takes my fancy

Sorchia's Universe

Magic, Mystery, a little Whisky, and a Cat

%d bloggers like this: